About this experiment
Dip a chosen metal into dilute acid, copper sulfate or zinc sulfate and test a prediction about reactivity. Acid can produce hydrogen, while a salt solution can plate a different metal onto the strip. Tracking the remaining and deposited solid shows why an actively reacting strip need not lose total solid mass.
Learning goals
- Compare metal reactivity using standard reduction-potential differences.
- Distinguish hydrogen evolution from displacement deposition.
- Apply mole and mass balances to the reacting strip and solution.
How to use it
- 1Dip magnesium, zinc, iron and copper separately into the acid and compare the predicted observations.
- 2Test iron in copper sulfate and inspect the copper deposit and changed solid mass.
- 3Test copper in zinc sulfate and explain the absence of displacement.
- 4Change metal mass and solution amount to find a limiting-reagent plateau, then record the gas or deposit.
The model
Assumptions
- Metals form divalent ions in this restricted model. Reference reduction potentials in volts are Mg -2.372, Zn -0.763, Fe -0.440 and Cu +0.340, with hydrogen at zero.
- A reaction is enabled when its reference cell potential is positive. Actual concentration-dependent electrode potentials, oxide films, passivation and kinetic barriers are excluded.
- The selected metal has a prescribed first-order progress constant. Rate differences are illustrative, not measured rate predictions. Solid mass includes both unreacted starting metal and deposited replacement metal.
Try this in class
- Q1Why can a magnesium strip gain total solid mass while magnesium atoms are leaving it?
- Q2Why is a standard reference potential not the actual voltage of every selected concentration?
Frequently asked questions
Should every favorable reaction make bubbles?
No. Acid reduction produces hydrogen in this model. Metal-ion displacement forms a solid deposit instead.
Does no visible change prove a real reaction is thermodynamically impossible?
No. Real observations also depend on surfaces and kinetics. This model uses a deliberately restricted standard-potential rule.
